We had a pleasant stay- we read some reviews prior to visiting and were prepared for the subway station noise on the west side of the hotel- where we stayed. We all had earplugs so we weren't affected. The hotel is very old- wood framed floors so the creaking from above guests is noticable. Knowing that the room you get is on the west (noisy) side of the hotel ahead of time would prepare other patrons. Great location- great staff- Great beds